---
description: Compare Square Payroll vs OnPay regarding their features, reviews, pricing, specifications, screenshots & more.
image: https://gdm-localsites-assets-gfprod.imgix.net/images/software_advice/og_logo-55146305bbe7b450bea05c18e9be9c9a.png
title: Square Payroll vs OnPay Comparison
---

Breadcrumb: [Home](/) > [Payroll Software for Accountants](/directory/3179/accountant-payroll/software) > [Square Payroll \<span\>vs\</span\> OnPay](https://www.softwareadvice.co.uk/compare/32608/40847/square-payroll/vs/onpay)

# Compare Square Payroll vs OnPay

Canonical: https://www.softwareadvice.co.uk/compare/32608/40847/square-payroll/vs/onpay

> Detailed comparison between Square Payroll and OnPay. Check ratings, reviews, pricing, and features to make the best decision for your business.

-----

## At a Glance

| Metric | Square Payroll | OnPay |
| **Overall rating** | 4.7/5 | 4.8/5 |
| **Total Reviews** | 620 | 461 |
| **Starting Price** | US$35.00 | US$49.00 |
| **Free Trial** | Yes | Yes |
| **Free Version** | No | No |
| **Deployment** | Cloud, SaaS, Web-based, Android (Mobile), iPhone (Mobile), iPad (Mobile) | Cloud, SaaS, Web-based |
| **Support** | Email/Help Desk, FAQs/Forum, Knowledge Base, Phone Support, Chat | Email/Help Desk, FAQs/Forum, Knowledge Base, Phone Support, Chat |
| **Training** | - | Live Online, Webinars, Documentation, Videos |

## Key features

### Square Payroll

- Accounting
- Accounting Integration
- Benefits Dashboard
- Benefits Management
- Dashboard
- Direct Deposit
- Employee Portal
- Employee Self Service
- For Accountants
- For Small Businesses
- Payroll Management
- Real-Time Reporting
- Reminders
- Reporting/Analytics
- Tax Calculation
- Tax Filing
- Time Tracking
- W-2 Preparation
- Wage Garnishment
- Web-based Deployment

### OnPay

- Accounting
- Accounting Integration
- Benefits Dashboard
- Benefits Management
- Dashboard
- Direct Deposit
- Employee Portal
- Employee Self Service
- For Accountants
- For Small Businesses
- Payroll Management
- Real-Time Reporting
- Reminders
- Reporting/Analytics
- Tax Calculation
- Tax Filing
- Time Tracking
- W-2 Preparation
- Wage Garnishment
- Web-based Deployment

## Links

- [View Square Payroll Profile](https://www.softwareadvice.co.uk/software/32608/square-payroll)
- [View OnPay Profile](https://www.softwareadvice.co.uk/software/40847/onpay)
- [View Original Comparison](https://www.softwareadvice.co.uk/compare/32608/40847/square-payroll/vs/onpay)

-----

## Structured Data

<script type="application/ld+json">
  {"@context":"https://schema.org","@graph":[{"name":"Square Payroll vs OnPay Comparison","description":"Compare Square Payroll vs OnPay regarding their features, reviews, pricing, specifications, screenshots & more.","url":"https://www.softwareadvice.co.uk/compare/32608/40847/square-payroll/vs/onpay","about":[{"@id":"https://www.softwareadvice.co.uk/software/32608/square-payroll#software"},{"@id":"https://www.softwareadvice.co.uk/software/40847/onpay#software"}],"breadcrumb":{"@id":"https://www.softwareadvice.co.uk/compare/32608/40847/square-payroll/vs/onpay#breadcrumblist"},"@type":["WebPage","CollectionPage"],"@id":"https://www.softwareadvice.co.uk/compare/32608/40847/square-payroll/vs/onpay#webpage","isPartOf":{"@id":"https://www.softwareadvice.co.uk/#website"},"inLanguage":"en-GB","publisher":{"@id":"https://www.softwareadvice.co.uk/#organization"}},{"name":"Square Payroll","description":"Square Payroll is a full-service payroll solution that helps small businesses pay employees through online payroll management and handle payroll tax. It can be integrated with a variety of payment processing tools, accounting software, and employee management systems including Square POS, QuickBooks, and more, and offers tools for automated tax filing, payroll process automation, benefits management such as health insurance and more. The online payroll service allows businesses to track workers' compensation and ensure payroll compliance at all times.\n\nSquare Payroll offers functionality to manage various employee types including salaried employees, hourly employees and contractors. The running payroll functionality allows businesses to pay employees and contractors based on their hours worked during a defined pay period, with data automatically pulled from the Square Point of Sale app. Square Payroll also automatically calculates paid time off, hours worked and total labor cost for each employee. Square Payroll also helps businesses automatically file taxes including new hire reports, W-2 forms and federal and state payroll taxes. Other key features include integrated timecards, employee benefits offerings and direct deposits.\n\nSquare Payroll pricing is based on the type and number of active employees a business has. The Square Payroll Android app and iOS app provide users with on-the-go payroll management with features such as sick leave tracking, vacation tracking, payroll calculation, timecard access, access to pay stubs, automatic payroll setup, payroll processing and more.","image":"https://gdm-catalog-fmapi-prod.imgix.net/ProductScreenshot/fbd3f9f8-791d-4c2c-84dc-62f8b6f2c605.png","url":"https://www.softwareadvice.co.uk/software/32608/square-payroll","@type":"SoftwareApplication","@id":"https://www.softwareadvice.co.uk/software/32608/square-payroll#software","applicationCategory":"BusinessApplication","publisher":{"@id":"https://www.softwareadvice.co.uk/#organization"},"aggregateRating":{"@type":"AggregateRating","ratingValue":4.7,"bestRating":5,"ratingCount":620},"offers":{"price":"35","@type":"Offer","priceCurrency":"USD"},"operatingSystem":"Cloud, Android, Platform ios, Platform ipad"},{"name":"OnPay","description":"OnPay is a cloud-based payroll solution that helps small businesses automate tax filing and payment workflows. Key features include employee self-onboarding, new hire reporting, automated payroll taxations and scheduled pay runs. OnPay provides an employee portal for updating information, onboarding and accessing past pay stubs and tax forms. Businesses can track their employees’ PTO, vacation and sick leave. The solution provides a document vault for storing contracts and employee notes. It offers integration with third-party applications like Xero, QuickBooks, Guideline, Vestwell and more.\n\nFeaturing a comprehensive suite of tools, OnPay simplifies payroll processing by automating calculations and tax deductions, offering direct deposit options and providing detailed reporting capabilities. This streamlined approach to payroll management ensures accuracy and compliance with tax regulations, relieving businesses of the burden of manual processing and minimizing the risk of errors. OnPay's HR management features centralize employee information, enable time-off requests, track benefits utilization and facilitate compliance with labor laws and regulations. By consolidating HR tasks into one platform, OnPay enhances organizational efficiency and empowers users to maintain accurate and up-to-date employee records.\n\nThe benefits management module of OnPay allows businesses to customize employee benefit offerings, track enrollments and manage contributions seamlessly. By simplifying benefits administration and ensuring compliance with regulations, OnPay helps businesses enhance employee satisfaction and retention by providing a platform for managing benefits effectively. OnPay's integrated platform facilitates the seamless flow of data between payroll, HR and benefits functions, reducing manual data entry and enhancing operational efficiency. By providing a holistic view of employee information and promoting data integration, OnPay enables businesses to make informed decisions and streamline administrative processes.\n\nAnother employee management feature offered by OnPay is 401(k) planning that helps employees plan for their retirement. The solution manages compliance, deductions and investment portfolios for users. It also allows employees to access their pay stubs and W2 forms online. OnPay offers services on a monthly subscription basis that includes support via phone and through an online knowledge base.","image":"https://gdm-catalog-fmapi-prod.imgix.net/ProductScreenshot/bf512a35-94de-4006-8487-581364a68afc.png","url":"https://www.softwareadvice.co.uk/software/40847/onpay","@type":"SoftwareApplication","@id":"https://www.softwareadvice.co.uk/software/40847/onpay#software","applicationCategory":"BusinessApplication","publisher":{"@id":"https://www.softwareadvice.co.uk/#organization"},"aggregateRating":{"@type":"AggregateRating","ratingValue":4.8,"bestRating":5,"ratingCount":461},"offers":{"price":"49","@type":"Offer","priceCurrency":"USD"},"operatingSystem":"Cloud"},{"@type":"BreadcrumbList","itemListElement":[{"name":"Home","position":1,"item":"/","@type":"ListItem"},{"name":"Payroll Software for Accountants","position":2,"item":"/directory/3179/accountant-payroll/software","@type":"ListItem"},{"name":"Square Payroll vs OnPay","position":3,"item":"https://www.softwareadvice.co.uk/compare/32608/40847/square-payroll/vs/onpay","@type":"ListItem"}],"@id":"https://www.softwareadvice.co.uk/compare/32608/40847/square-payroll/vs/onpay#breadcrumblist"}]}
</script>